Season of Camel Fairs in Pakistan

Photograph for Mangrota Camel Fair

Note: To know more about Mangrota Camel Fair, please visit: http://saves.org.pk/pub/6.pdf

Camel plays very pivotal role in the sociocultural and socioeconomic life of its herders throughout the world. Pakistan is the home of almost one million camels belong to many diverse breeds. There are three main habitats of camel in the country, i.e. desert, plain lands and mountains. The camel in the above three ecosystems are very diversify from each-other and among themselves in the same habitat. This difference makes a beautiful biodiversity of camel in the country and making more than 16 breeds of camel. Pakistan is rich with camel culture and every tribe of camel keepers know all the attributes of their type of camel. At the end of their camel year, they celebrate camel mela or fair in many parts of the country. Such melas are the best place where the camel herders meet and share their experiences and situation. Thousands of camel are bring and these melas are use as a unique and major market place for camel business. Such fairs are mostly link with some spiritual or religious rituals and the camel herders link camel with spirituality.
Here below are the names of the famous melas of the country. Most of them are held in the months of October, November and December.

The most important camel events at country level in Pakistan are; 

• Anayat Shah
• Karorr Pakka
• Sakhi Sarwar
• Shah Jamal
• Odaro lal
• Mangrota
• Jalsa (DG Khan)
• Sibbi Mela
• Chnan peer (Cholistan)
• and Thandla

These events provide a noble chance for camel stake holders to meet and enjoy different events like folk music, camel dance, racing and camel fighting etc. The same events are the key business points of camel.
The government support is very limited in these cultural events. There is always lack of facilities, especially water sources are very scarce. 

Also, some people bring camels with some epidemic disease which causes havoc losses. 
Being the organizer of Camel Association of Pakistan (CAP), I hereby appeal government to please take interest and help the camel herders and pastoralists. Also, these events can be good sources of revenue generation if tourists are attracted.

Camel, the animal of future

Camel is the integral part of culture and back bone of the pastoral economy in the arid zones of the world. Camel provides safe, healthy and biologically organic milk. Camel is use for draft purpose in the harsh, hostile and inaccessible territories of the world. Camel is hardy, with very unique biological features, enabling him to consume water and feed sources very judiciously. Camel produces food item, especially milk in the very low inputs system. The special feature of camel makes it exceptional to combat the soaring sun shine and high ambient temperature. 

Camel tolerates extreme weather conditions and produce milk when other livestock special strives to sustain life. Camel is one of the best tools to combat the climate change and future food insecurity problem. Unfortunately, camel itself and its production system is under threat. In many parts of the world it is neglected and hardly spaced in the research and policy of governments. The major threat to camel is its habitat demolition. There is utmost need of time to save and conserve our camel.

Save the planet by killing camels”: Australia’s solution to global warming? A false and stupid solution

Save the planet by killing camels”: Australia’s solution to global warming? A false and stupid solution

Recently, a media release, titled “The Australian authorities will kill feral camels to save the planet”, revealed the intention of the Australian government to fight global warming by killing camels. “It was suggested that the methane emission by camels in the bush is greater than that from cattle and that the feral camels in Australia are contributing significantly to global greenhouse gas emissions. So, the solution is simple: kill the camels and Australia will contribute to the global effort to save the planet. There are several scientific and empirical responses to further such a statement. The estimation of methane emission by camels is based on cattle data extrapolation, ignoring the fact that the metabolic efficiency of camel is higher than that of cattle and that camels are able to produce 20% more milk by eating 20% less food, they have different digestive system and are more efficient in the utilization of poor quality roughages. The rumen flora digesting the roughages is also different than cattle, and their energetic metabolism is closer to monogastric than that of true ruminants such as cattle and sheep. Therefore, the estimation of camel methane emission is quite debatable, as well as the estimated feral population.

It is true that camel overpopulation could generate environmental problems and that requires proper management, but to take such a decision by targeting camels and to consider them as a major contributor to methane emission among other herbivores in Australia is not reasonable. With less than 28 million heads at world level, the camel population represents less than 1% of the total herbivorous biomass in the world.  Elsewhere, camel population is living in extensive arid lands where the carbon and methane emission is among the lowest at the surface of the earth.

The International Society of Camelid Research and Development (ISOCARD) with more than 300 of its members from all over the world, and representing different fields of research, considers the decision to point out the feral camels as one of the main culprits in generating the greenhouse gases in the Australian bush as a scientific aberration. Instead the feral dromedary camels should be seen as an incomparable resource in arid environments. They can and should be exploited for food (meat and milk), skin and hides, tourism etc. We believe that the good-hearted people and innovating nation of Australia can come up with better and smarter solutions than eradicating camels in inhumane ways.

For ISOCARD: the executive committee

A fatal Respiratory Camel Disease

Summary

A highly contagious respiratory disease was first reported from Washuk, Dalbandin and Panjgur (Chaghai Kaharan desert) districts of Balochistan province of Pakistan in the month of July, 2010. The disease was frivolously taken as the results of the dust storm and dry spells. According to the history, the disease was spread with the dust fill winds after the long drought period in the driest areas of the province of Balochistan and adjoining areas of Iran and Afghanistan. In other areas the disease was spread by the marketed and migrated animals. The signs and symptoms of the disease are comprised of white sticky mucus nasal discharge, nasal blockage with thick scar formation (partially plugging) on nasal orifice, no regurgitation, ultimately the animal goes off feed. A treatment with Amoxicillin Trihydrate (150 mg per ml) at the dose rate of 1ml per 10kg body weight was provided by local veterinarians and other practitioners. A single shot of the above said antibiotic recovered the animal within 12 hour. All the physiological activity restored within 24 hours.

Picture of an affected camel from Sibi Balochistan

The second report came from the Suleiman Mountainous region and Thar Desert of Sind of Pakistan with the same sign and symptoms. The disease did not cause any mortality but was highly epidemic and caused high level of morbidity. The disease responds quick and positively to penicillin. The animal treated recovered in 3 days. The third and alarming report came from Cholistan Desert and southern part of KPK of Pakistan. That testimony was frightening with high mortality. Also a high mortality was also reported from Western Indian state of Rajasthan. Some additional signs were also reported; like sudden death after the onset of the disease and water omission from the mouth of the dead animal just after the death.

Symptoms of the Disease

The symptoms reported from Chaghai Kharan and other parts of Balochistan, Sindh and adjoining areas of KPK were summarized from the reports (sent from the veterinarians from the field) and personal observation of the sick animals brought from the affected areas in the camel market at Quetta are as following.

· Transmission through man and animals

· No age restriction

· Sign appear within 24 hours after introduction of an animal or herd men from the affected areas

· Highly contagious

· Dullness and depression and loss of appetite.

· Nasal blockage with thick scar formation (partially plugging) on nasal orifice

· Nasal discharge opaque in color and blockage make a hard scar

· Coughing and some animal do open mouth breathing

· Gradual loss in body weight until the disease exists

· Recover within 21 days naturally, if not treated

· Animal recover when the pus discharge from ear (some camel herders observation) and the pus color is bluish white

· Salivation increase during the disease period

· Pus like laceration from the eyes during disease

· Mortality is very rare in Balochistan but reported from the southern part of KPK

· In KPK, some herders observed about 10% mortality in camel herds, which occurs suddenly

The signs and symptoms reported from Cholistan desert of Pakistan were somewhat different and are presented in the ensuing lines.

· The disease is highly epidemic and about 80% of the camel herd was affected

· Sticky white nasal discharge

A dead animal with the new disease in Cholistan (courtesy Dr Sohail Khan)

· A blood tint nasal discharge was observed

· The sick animal usually keeps their head upward

· The animal goes emaciated and weak

· The mortality rate is high

· The death occurs within three days after the onset of the disease.

Postpartum Findings

The postmortem findings were reported from a field veterinarian (Sohail Khan) along with the pictures of sick and dead animals. Larynx of the dead camel was swollen and the whole trachea was lacerated. The lungs were filled with sticky exudates. There were black spots on the lungs and were fused with the ribs. Whole the respiratory tract was filled with the blood tint sticky materials.

Laboratory finding

The only laboratory finding of the disease reported from scientists in Central Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory (CVDL), Tandojam Sindh. According to the findings, Bacterium (Pasturralla) was responsible for this disease, though other types of bacterium like Streptococci were also found in the samples. The same findings are also reported from the laboratory findings from BZU Multan. But still we cannot reach to final conclusion either the disease is viral or bacterial. The findings for bacterial positive can be link with the secondary bacterial infection.

Discussion

The Scientists say that the symptoms described could point to a respiratory viral infection with bacterial complications taking into account the contagiousness nature of the outbreak. However, they said, it is hard to come up with a definitive diagnosis unless one confirm by laboratory methods. The positive response of the disease to Penicillin might be link with the secondary bacterial infection.

Hanwant Singh of LPPS in Rajasthan from a famous camel keeping community of Raika reported about camel respiratory disease with many camels dying. According to him disease is reported from all corner of the Rajasthan. In contrary to Chaghai Kharan desert, the Raika pastoral of Rajasthan doubt that the disease might be link with the massive rain fall in last moon soon (2010). The disease comes along with nasal discharge and the Animal husbandry department is calling it "bronchopneumonia". Ilse Kohler Rollefson, project director of the LPP in Rajasthan reported that hundreds or more likely thousands of camels are currently dying in India and Pakistan and maybe adjoining countries due to the outbreak of a mysterious respiratory disease to which there is no organized response and which has not been diagnosed.

Bernard Faye, France from the famous institute of CIRAD commented on the disease and said that probably there is bacterial contamination but the origin of the disease is probably viral.

There is no doubt that the disease is viral but I doubt if it is PPR. The signs of PPR are quite different, i.e. diarrhea, laceration, gums decomposition and severe emaciation etc.

The scientists in CVDL Tandojam, after lab examination revealed that a Bacterium (pasturralla) was responsible for this disease, though other types of bacterium like Streptoccoi were also found in the samples.

According to Dr. Abdelmalik I. Khalafalla, from Syria, similar respiratory killing disease was reported in Sudan, Ethiopia and kenya (1996-2006) and after lab investigations it turns to be caused by PPR virus, a morbillivirus of the Paramyxoviridae. He advised to send swabs, lymph node and lungs samples to CIRAD or IAEA laboratories for lab diagnosis. In case it a PPR in camel’s susceptible, non infected camels may be vaccinated with sheep PPR vaccine, the same stopped the progress of the disease in Sudan. He said that he is ready to assist.

Renaud Lancelot from CIRAD, France, affirmed that he at CIRAD is very much interested and ready to collaborate. He further suggested that it would also be important to check other pathogens such as Pasteurella and Mycoplasma, the latter being difficult to diagnose. He further offered that samples could be to CIRAD, and they will share samples with Adama Diallo at IAEA.

Suggestion

I would suggest you advise Vet authorities in the affected areas to collect lymph nodes and lungs from dead animals and nasal swabs from clinically sick camels and submit for lab diagnosis by PCR and ELISA. Kindly read the abstract on PPR in camels and let me know about the epidemiology of the disease in Pakistan. I also received similar observation from Iran. Let us establish a network to assist in exchange information on camel diseases. The international scientists suggested that the veterinarians in the affected areas might collect lymph nodes and lungs from dead animals and nasal swabs from clinically sick camels and submit for lab diagnosis by PCR and ELISA.

The Swedish scientists of SVA, Kerstin and Set proposed a task force and also a detailed and practical operating manual for sampling (information from animal keepers and clinical examination), how to sample, which animals to sample, how to submit samples, what to analyze, how to interpret results and how to act depending on the interpretation) would be useful. The manual should be useful not just for these respiratory disease outbreaks but also for other infectious diseases, to be prepared for future outbreaks.